Chicks
Pullet or Cockerel? How to Tell Hens from Roosters by Age
Straight-run chicks are sold unsexed, and even sexed chicks come with a margin of error: McMurray Hatchery guarantees 90% accuracy on all sexed poultry, and Valley Hatchery guarantees 90% for most breeds. Telling a pullet (young female) from a cockerel (young male) gets easier with every week. This guide sets out which signs show at which age, from down color at hatch to spurs at almost a year, and how reliable each one is according to the sources listed at the bottom.
Signs by age at a glance
| Age | What to look at | Works for | How reliable |
|---|---|---|---|
| At hatch | Down color: red sex-link males hatch white, females buff or red; black sex-link chicks are all black, males with a white dot on the head (University of Kentucky) | First-generation sex-link crosses only | No figure in the extension sources |
| At hatch | Down pattern: males paler with blurred markings, females darker with a broad dark stripe over head, neck and rump (Legbar, per Wikipedia) | Autosexing breeds such as the Legbar, Cambar and Rhodebar | No figure given |
| At hatch | Head spot: large white spot on males, smaller and narrower on females | Purebred Barred Plymouth Rocks | About 80% (Poultry Extension) |
| At hatch | Wing spot: a white spot on the down over the wing web in males | Rhode Island Reds and New Hampshires | "Not always accurate" because spot size varies (Poultry Extension) |
| 1–3 days | Feather sexing: length of the wing primaries against the coverts | Feather-sexable crosses, such as commercial white-egg strains | Readable only in this window (Poultry Extension) |
| 4–6 weeks | Larger comb and wattles and a more angular head in males; females smaller and more refined | Most breeds | The "most convenient" method for small flocks (Mississippi State) |
| About 3 months | Long, pointed saddle feathers on cockerels; curved sickle tail feathers a little later | Most breeds, not hen-feathered ones | My Pet Chicken FAQ; Poultry Extension says only males have saddle feathers |
| About 4–5 months | Crowing | Males; some hens crow too | Starts anywhere from about 2 to 8–9 months (My Pet Chicken) |
| Under 6 months, then 6 months on | Names change: pullet and cockerel, then hen and cock or rooster | All chickens | Nebraska Extension's growth chart |
| 7–12 months | Spurs: the bony core begins to form at 7–8 months; the sheath grows from about 0.5 mm at hatch to 20–30 mm by 12 months in modern commercial breeds | Mainly males; some hens grow spurs | Doherty et al. (2021) |
At hatch: chicks you can sex by color
Birds reverse the mammal system: males are ZZ and females ZW, and the genes for barring, silver versus gold and feathering speed sit on the Z chromosome (University of Kentucky; Poultry Extension). Two kinds of chicks use this:
- Sex-links are first-generation crosses of a rooster of one breed over hens of another. The parent breeds, chick colors and why the reverse cross fails are on the sex-link chickens page. Their offspring will not breed true (Kentucky).
- Autosexing breeds are purebreds whose chicks can be sexed by the color and markings of the down. Reginald Punnett and Michael Pease at Cambridge made the first, the Cambar, in 1928, and the Legbar about ten years later (Wikipedia). Oklahoma State describes Cream Legbar males as a lighter brown with a small bleached spot on the head and females as a deeper shade with stripes along the back. The Poultry Club of Great Britain notes the first Cream Legbars were crestless and laid white eggs; blue eggs came later from Araucana crosses.
Wikipedia's chick sexing article adds that Rhode Island Red and New Hampshire chicks with chipmunk stripes are almost always female.
Feather sexing in the first three days
Feather sexing works only in strains bred for it; Mississippi State notes that most breeds lack the trait and both sexes look identical. In a feather-sexable cross (a fast-feathering male over slow-feathering females), the sons are slow-feathering and the daughters fast-feathering (Poultry Extension).
- Check the age. The difference in length between the primary and covert wing feathers shows between one and three days after hatch; after that this cross cannot be used for sexing (Poultry Extension).
- Spread one wing gently and find the long primary feathers along the edge and the covert feathers lying over them.
- Primaries clearly longer than the coverts: pullet.
- Coverts as long as or longer than the primaries: cockerel.
- Not sure, or not a feather-sexable cross? Wait for the growing-bird signs from 4–6 weeks.
- Pullet wing, 1–3 days: in a feather-sexable cross, the primaries are clearly longer than the coverts lying over them
- Cockerel wing, 1–3 days: the coverts are as long as or longer than the primaries
- Cockerel hackle: longer, narrower and pointed; saddle feathers, which only males grow, are long and pointed too
- Pullet hackle: rounded, oval tip
- Cockerel comb: larger, develops earlier and, in single-comb breeds such as the Leghorn, stands upright; wattles larger
- Pullet comb: smaller; in single-comb breeds it typically flops to one side
From 4 weeks: signs in growing birds
At hatch, males and females weigh the same (Poultry Extension). Mississippi State says the secondary sex characteristics can usually be used from 4 to 6 weeks; Wikipedia gives the same range for small farmers without a professional sexer.
| Sign | Cockerel | Pullet | Caveat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comb and wattles | Larger, develop earlier; single combs stand upright (Poultry Extension) | Smaller; single combs typically flop to one side | Nebraska Extension notes pullets' combs also grow and turn red, and pea combs make sexing harder (Poultry Extension) |
| Head and body | More angular head (Mississippi State); larger body (Poultry Extension) | Smaller and more refined | Compare birds of the same breed and age |
| Hackle (neck) feathers | Longer, more pointed, narrower | Rounded, oval | My Pet Chicken says the difference is clearest high on the neck, near the head |
| Saddle feathers | Present; long and pointed by about 3 months | None; the back feathers are rounded | Poultry Extension: only males have saddle feathers |
| Tail | Shiny, curving sickle feathers appear after the saddle feathers | No sickle feathers | My Pet Chicken FAQ |
| Crest (Polish, Sultans, Crevecoeurs) | Pointed | Soft topknot | Poultry Extension |
| Color pattern | Differs between the sexes in many purebred varieties (eXtension) | Check your breed's standard | |
| Crowing | Usually from 4–5 months | Normally silent | Some hens crow (My Pet Chicken) |
| Spurs | Large spurs on the back of the shank (eXtension) | Usually none | Hens of some breeds, and older hens with hormone changes, can grow spurs (Doherty et al.) |
Breeds that break the rules
- Sebright and Campine: the males are "hen-feathered," so feather shape does not help (Poultry Extension; eXtension). For Sebrights, My Pet Chicken says comb and wattle size are about the only easy way to tell.
- Silkie: sexing is difficult because the feathers lack barbs (Poultry Extension). My Pet Chicken lists long streamers in the male's crest, a larger comb and, in non-bearded birds, larger wattles.
- Pea-comb and other small-comb breeds: small combs make comb-based sexing harder (Poultry Extension).
Where the sources differ
- Combs. Poultry Extension and Mississippi State treat larger combs and wattles as a main early sign; My Pet Chicken calls comb size and redness one indicator but "not usually reliable."
- Crowing. eXtension says males crow and females do not. My Pet Chicken says hens can crow too, gives 4–5 months as typical for roosters, and reports starts as early as 2 months and as late as 8–9 months.
- Spurs. eXtension lists large spurs as a male trait; Doherty et al. (2021) report that females occasionally develop spurs that reach the same shape and grow at a comparable rate.
- Autosexing history. Wikipedia's auto-sexing article dates the California Grey to the 1930s in Modesto; its chick sexing article credits the California Gray to Dryden Farms in the 1950s.
Methods that do not work
Poultry Extension: egg shape does not show the sex of the chick, the string-and-needle test is unreliable, and these folk methods are right about "fifty-fifty." Candling cannot show the sex of an embryo either. Vent sexing works but takes extensive training; Poultry Extension notes there are very few schools that still teach it.
Checklist: hen or rooster?
- Write down the hatch date and compare the bird with the age table above.
- Know the chick type. Sex-link or autosexing chicks can be sorted at hatch; straight-run chicks cannot, and McMurray does not guarantee an equal number of males and females in a straight-run order.
- Use several signs together: comb and wattles, then hackle and saddle feathers, then crowing. Names of the feather tracts are on the chicken anatomy page; terms such as straight run and sexed are in the glossary.
- Allow for the hatchery margin. A 90% guarantee means an occasional cockerel among sexed pullets.
- Check rooster rules for your address before the crowing starts; see how to check local chicken rules.
- Keep raising them the same way until you are sure; brooder care is in chick care for the first 8 weeks.
Sources
- Jacquie Jacob, Poultry Extension — Sexing Day-Old Chicks
- Jacquie Jacob, Poultry Extension — Sex-Linked Traits in Poultry
- Mississippi State University Extension — Sexing of Day-Old Chicks
- University of Kentucky, Animal & Food Sciences — Poultry: Sex-Linked Crosses
- eXtension Small and Backyard Flocks — How can I distinguish male and female chickens? (2012)
- Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County — Chicken Growth & Development (PDF)
- Oklahoma State University, Breeds of Livestock — Legbar Chickens
- The Poultry Club of Great Britain — Autosexing Legbar
- Doherty et al. (2021), International Journal of Osteoarchaeology — Estimating the age of domestic fowl cockerels through spur development (open-access copy)
- McMurray Hatchery — The McMurray Difference (sexing guarantee)
- Valley Hatchery — Customer Guarantees
- My Pet Chicken — How can I tell if my juvenile bird is a rooster? (retailer FAQ)
- My Pet Chicken — At what age does a rooster begin crowing? (retailer FAQ)
- Wikipedia — Chick sexing (secondary)
- Wikipedia — Auto-sexing (secondary)